Planning Application Seething Wells Elmbridge Council 2022/1667

                                                        We know who the sunken boat belonged to......

This objection is work in progress; here is the link elmbridge.gov.uk to the latest, in a series of failed applications; in this case for a pontoon, perpendicular to the river wall, to provide moorings either side. Pedestrian access will be constructed from the Portsmouth Road to the river wall, with a route down to the pontoons. The shape of the pontoon and the pedestrian access is slightly different between the documents, depending on whether you read the Flood Risk Assessment or the iCON consulting plans, sometimes a T shape, sometimes a ship-shape.

Heritage and Bats

Some of the documents presented in the planning file are under one corporate logo and appear to be a selection from previous planning application 2018/3343 for 2 very thin town houses. These include the Heritage Assessment which ignores most of the heritage at the site. I include the wharf in my objection even though the applicants present  to us only a narrow strip of land (or NSoL) and not the blue line plan, which should detail everything under Cascina's ownership. The Flood Risk Assessment accompanying this application indicates at Fig. 6 that egress and access is via the gates on the wharf opposite the small pumping station or Building of Townscape Merit which is also a bat roost; not mentioned in the Heritage Documents nor the 'Ecology and the no - Bat - survey' report.

Neither does it mention the Listed Lambeth Tunnel which will be impacted by the the proposed pedestrian access. The tunnel was found to be  used by bats in surveys as was more recently, its parallel twin the Chelsea Tunnel, where three species of bat were located during surveys commissioned in 2019. For these reasons alone the application should be dismissed. But it gets worse. This Site was mentioned in the Step 3 Waterworks report 2000 commissioned by Heritage England as of National Importance so chipping away at the bit that lies in Elmbridge and pretending its a NSoL is quite naughty. 

If you are objecting to this application and discussing it's importance for birds you may need to tell Elmbridge council that this NSoL actually spills into Kingston and is part of a Heritage Site of National Importance. I don't know how they would monitor such an access route.

There is no record of professional credentials for any Icon employee, or directors, by online searching. The company's website www.iconsulting.uk.com, given in the documents, doesn't seem to work. As such, it's hard to confirm the expertise on proposals and impacts pertaining to wildlife, ecology, heritage, built structures, etc.This means some of the drawings lack clarity and the features are not identified such as the Lambeth and Chelsea Tunnels in fact, they are more like cartoons. 

The Ecology report was prepared in March by external consultants but the advice given by them is that no further surveys are required yet they are aware of the proximity of the SMINC, SINC, MoL etc. This is the most recent Site of Nature Conservation Importance (SINC) review for the Seething Wells Filter Beds which is in Kingston.

This is a SINC (Borough Grade 1), and still confirmed as such, and as of "notable value", in the recent SINC Review (December 2020):-

"3.15  Seething Wells Filter Beds as identified as being 'at risk' due to the current management practices, which include the treatment and removal of vegetation and trees, being implemented, which has significantly altered the extent and value of the habitats present. This has included the loss of species-rich grassland habitat, which supported calcareous grassland species that are unique to the borough and quality of wetland habitats present. Given the nature of the site, which continues to support wetland habitats, as well as its relationship with the River Thames and its geological character, the site is considered to continue to be of notable value."

The 'current management practices' alluded to are the persistent spraying with herbicide under a licence provided by the Environment Agency for a plant that has never been recorded on the site so that the ecological interest could be totally degraded. The ecology report states that this has contributed to it becoming Open Mosaic Habitat 'but none of the indicators were present'.  

DEFRA and Buglife state that Open Mosaic Habitat on previously developed land is defined by vegetation structure and not specific vegetation types. Open Mosaic Habitat is Priority Habitat because it can support specialist invertebrates and Schedule 1 birds such as the black redstart that has been recorded on nearby heritage buildings and and at Surrey County Hall. Surveys in 2019 stated that 'although no breeding black redstarts were located then, the location is perfect habitat for foraging birds'.

So lets look deeper into this 'insignificant' NSoL (narrow strip of land). We have already said that it will have an impact on the protected Lambeth Tunnel portal. In the 2018, application to Elmbridge council, it included a plan to develop a thoroughfare into the site from the Portsmouth road (on the NSoL). Ecological Surveys found a grass snake in the NSoL and reptile mitigation was included on the planning file (recently, on social media, a grass snake was filmed attempting to move around the wall on the Elmbridge side).

In addition, the 2018 application had a 25m buffer zone drawn around the Daubenton's bat maternity colony 2018. This was the area designed to be a protective shield to avoid disturbing a bat. Otherwise a licence to disturb a bat would be required. So in this case we are presented with an ecology report that misses and dismisses most of the ecology,  fails to undertake species surveys and the mitigation hierarchy ignored. But do not worry as we have bushes planted in the Open Mosaic Habitat.

Lighting

Recently an unauthorised electrical cabinet was installed on the wharf and Kingston Council decided to take no action (to date). This was perhaps because there is already an enforcement notice at the site. This is  the cabinet that will no doubt provide the connections to operate the lights on the pontoons and pedestrian access. The Ecology Report cops out and states that lighting should follow BCT Guidance. 

Bat Conservation Trust does not give advice to the level of lighting there should be near a Daubenton's maternity colony, because there should NOT be any light. Lighting a Daubenton's bat roost will have profound consequences for the movement of the colony to foraging areas.  This is the darkest part of the River Thames for some distance and the reason the bats have been using the barge tunnel for many years. Elmbridge Council have signed up to 'not allowing any new lighting along river corridors' (see leaflet below) Surrey CC funded the leaflet.

Non - breeding bats use locations along the river wall and they would be severely affected by this application - bats are entombed when lights are shone on their roost sites. This application should be refused.

                                              Send SAE for copy of the leaflet, post requests in the comments box.


Comments

Post a Comment

Please share your thoughts

Most viewed

Heritage Trees part 2: street trees.

Image
  Oaks and maples Cambridge Gardens 2019   Street trees can often be the most beautiful objects in our streets. They are important to their communities as well as having environmental benefits. They are a living history in our landscape and can have particular connections. They may be fragments of a previous landscape incorporated into a modern street scene, such as the oaks at Cambridge Gardens once  part of the Duke of Cambridge's estate.  A great read with information on how to research street trees is a  History of Street Trees by Dr. M. Johnston.  London plane trees CRE 1976 Beech tree, Chesterton Terrace 1976 Studies show that the difference in local tree cover can reflect the various socio-economic groups. In Victorian times middle class areas were planted with many street trees or had higher quality front gardens than working class districts; now referred to as 'green equity'. It can be demonstrated by looking at old photos of the seven roads that were
Read more

Fishing the Hogsmill

Image
Fly-fishing the Hogsmill   It is interesting to see the river from a different perspective: the Hogsmill is popular with anglers at this time of year; although it is unusual to see someone fly- fishing. A chub has just been caught on bread and it looks a good size. Trout are sometimes seen in the Hogsmill and can sit in the weir notch by the school. Our own Richard Jefferies in his book 'Nature Near London'  remarked on the Hogsmill trout as far up as Tolworth Hall Bridge (now the A240). chub    This fish was carefully unhooked and orientated in the swim where it soon finds it way - probably to the next father and son - sitting further upstream. These anglers have caught the 'ghost' koi within the last two weeks and appear to be the second successful pair to catch the pond-escapee in the last few days. Ghost koi are a British invention. They were produced by accident in the early 80’s when a farmer allowed a mirror carp and a koi to spawn together. The offspring
Read more

Seething Wells: they've done it again

Image
The last day of May, I went to see if I could find the black redstart that had been widely reported, no luck but it will turn up again on one of the old buildings. The lush vegetation was looking beautiful between the Filter Beds at Seething Wells. I made a note of the breeding birds: goldfinches twinkling away, blue tits gathering food, sand martins flying over the FB's (only two this year unfortunately) moorhens and some scruffy little coot chicks entangled in the algal blooms.   Proud parents were showing off their four Canada chicks; they can cover a lot of ground in a short space of time they were soon feeding on water pepper and bistort gleaned from  the ziggerat-sided basins. A song thrush sang from the wharf alongside greenfinches as well as the seasonal chiff chaff; although this year all numbers are down, reflecting not only the topsy-turvy Spring but also the continued tumble in insect numbers (even seed eating birds are dependent on insects to feed their young).
Read more